NEW YORK REPORT: A teacher, reporting from Lower Manhattan on the situation in New York City after Sandy

Dear Substance Comrades... My family and I are doing fine. We live on the lower east side in Manhattan, below 34th St. where power, out since Monday evening, started to come back on Friday around 5 P.M. Power outages remain in some lower Manhattan areas particularly large buildings where the basements flooded. In the other boros and towns in NJ, Westchester, Rockland, Nassau and Suffolk counties, some folks will remain without power until trees are removed and power lines can be repaired.

The eight-foot tidal surge wiped out some sea-level communities. Subways are still not running in Lower Manhattan as of last night. I am just catching up with email. Julie Cavanagh, MORE's candidate in the upcoming UFT elections, emailed reports on the Red Hook projects in a low lying Brooklyn area by the harbor where her school PS 15 is located. The area was badly flooded and residents were still without power and water as of last night.

Another teacher, Marjorie Stamberg wrote that the city was saying that power at the Red Hook projects may remain out until 11/11, and she warned that folks should be on the look out for efforts by the city housing authority to use this disaster to push out public housing residents as was done in New Orleans. I read similar reports from the projects in Coney Island.

The scenes from the gated community, Breezy Point, which lies at the tip of the Rockaway peninsula have been widely publicized by the media. NYC Teachers were instructed to return to work on Friday even while the subway service was only partially restored and buses were jammed. It took me three hours to get to work and the same to return. For many teachers it was just impossible to get in. It remains to be seen whether the city will require teachers to use personal leave time if they were unable to return on Friday.

Schools are slated to be reopened on Monday. I think it is obvious that the feds responded better in NYC than they did in New Orleans. This is partially due to the difference between the administrations, but also due to the housing pattern in NYC where for example you can find a million dollar condo located across the street from a public housing project. This grates on the real estate interests to no end and they will be looking to revamp infrastructure while at the same time speed up efforts to turn Manhattan into the ultimate gentrified gated community for the wealthy surrounded as it is by water.

The heroes of this disaster are the working class people who supported each other and worked tirelessly to restore essential services. Thank the working class for the public sector. No private charters or privatized transportation companies would respond to human need as a fully funded public sector can. There were very few reports of looting or violence even though people were without food and water and had no access to cash machines or open supermarkets.

The Daily News today carried a report of 11 arrests outside a Coney Island supermarket across from a housing project. One of the men arrested holding toilet paper, water and candy pleaded with officers saying 'I'm no criminal, what am I supposed to do let my grandmother go hungry?' Similar to Katrina, if you are white you are "foraging" for essential supplies, if you are a Black or Latino you are "looting." Bail was set for $20,000 and the Brooklyn DA says that they will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

The climate change disasters have opened up new arenas of class warfare as the rich seek to guard their wealth and power even as the ship is sinking. It seems clear to me that public sector workers and our unions will increasingly emerge as the true leaders of society to the extent that we identify our working conditions with the living and working conditions of the working class and society as a whole.

We in NYC enter into another season of struggle against school closings and privatization with this heightened awareness.

Thanks again to the CTU which has pointed the way.

One final observation, Richard Grasso, former head of the stock exchange was on Bloomberg radio all day Thursday patting himself on the back for waiting to reopen Wall Street out of consideration for the people operating the exchange. 'Sure we can trade electronically but what about the people?' he repeated. The financial sector doesn't need the real estate, but the NYC real estate industry does, and I think the latter group in particular has the jitters about climate change.

Romney and his financial sector clowns can dismiss climate change, but it will prove to be a political dead end. This is an interesting and potentially significant fissure in the ruling elite that may pressure the so called "radical" and liberal think tanks and non profits to reassess their slavish non political subservience to their funding sources. A historic opportunity presents itself. If the "white" led unions, affordable housing groups, and parent groups can break through their historic indifference to racial equality and demand justice for all and not just the so called "middle class" (which I think is often used as a code word for all those "white" Reagan democrat males now wondering what went wrong), a real mass based alternative to the oligarchy will continue to grow.

Peace, Sean Ahern


November 4, 2012 at 9:34 AM

By: Gladys M Sotomayor

NYC Teacher report Lower Mn after Sandy

Thank you Sean for you article. We must remain vigilante on what steps we as teachers take and where it will lead us through this for our sakes and that of our families, students and their families. WE are the ones who pick up the pieces when tragedy strikes. So here goes.

I am originally from Chicago and now a NYC teacher in Brooklyn. I worked briefly at a nearby shelter and was care taking my two ill during and after the storm. In addition as an ATR I was assigned to report to a school in Williamsburg. Although I am exhausted from this week, I wonder how many of us have had far more hardships, how are we coping or who is supporting us? We are expected to return to work deal with our students. As a parent I received an email from my son's Bay Ridge school on how they will do what ever it takes to support our children. Again I ask what about us? We need to be each others support too and share what happens in the aftermath of the hurricane. Considering this "school/ teacher evaluation reform" climate we can not assume that all administrators as far up as it can go up the chain of command will show genuine prophetic compassionate leadership. We must find time to heal too and provide actionable support. Be well all, to you Sean and family, NYC teachers and loved one, CTU supporters,

Gladys M. Sotomayor

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

5 + 1 =