Jeb Bush (whom some are calling 'Bush III') begins campaign to become the next 'education president' while praising Obama and Duncan's corporate approach to 'school reform'

Largely below the radar in Chicago and a number of other major cities which are battling terrible cuts in public education and continued privatization as well as a host of other ills (see "youth violence") once again the Bush family has a long-term strategic plan to continue to hold the high ground politically. This time, the family standard bearer is Jeb Bush, who is currently barnstorming on behalf of corporate school reform, praising Barack Obama and Arne Duncan as kindred spirits, and positioning himself and a carefully constructed version of his work as Governor of Florida as the next national hero of the education reform movement.

On October 9, the St. Petersburg Times reported as follows:


U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan (above) announced in Chicago at the Advance Illinois breakfast on June 19, 2009 that he would be barnstorming the country with Newt Gingrich and Al Sharpton to promote the education policies of the Obama administration. Now Sharpton has suggested that the tour get a fourth person — former Florida Governor Jeb Bush, brother of former President George W. Bush and son of former President George H. W. Bush. Jeb Bush is positioning himself for a run for the Presidency and has an educational foundation that promotes corporate school reform to help him. He claims that Florida schools showed great gains during his time as governor thanks to his "standards and accountability" reforms. Recently, he told the press he agrees completely with the Obama administration's reforms and supports Arne Duncan. Substance photo by George N. Schmidt at the June 19, 2009 Advance Illinois breakfast in Chicago.In the past few months, Jeb Bush has been living the chorus of an old country song, hitting the highways and biways of America — or at least its airports — as a rambling salesman for school reform.

He's been everywhere, man. Nashville. Indianapolis. Phoenix. Washington D.C. this week. Atlanta later this month.

At every stop, the former Republican governor is talking education and pitching Florida's "cocktail of reforms" to lawmakers and business leaders as a potential remedy for their sick schools.

"It's kind of hard to continue to argue" that Florida isn't boosting student achievement, Bush said in an interview. "It's like policy makers in Washington continuing to fight the Cold War."

Love him or hate him, Bush, 56, is barnstorming his way into national education circles. Supporters say evidence is on his side. Critics concede his timing is good.

Some Bush initiatives, like grading schools from A to F, remain unpopular here. But national test scores show Florida is on the move. And other states are taking notice.

"There are multiple things (from Florida) we need to look at and either adopt them wholesale or adapt them," said Arizona House Speaker Kirk Adams.

Meanwhile, the political lines that used to divide education reformers into predictable camps are blurring rapidly.

In Florida, a majority of Democratic lawmakers now support tax-credit vouchers, which Bush backed in 2001 over near-universal Democratic opposition. And nationally, it's a Democrat — D.C. schools chancellor Michelle Rhee — who is most gung ho about gutting teacher tenure.

"It's definitely a good time (for Bush) if he wants to engage on the issue," said Andy Rotherham, an influential blogger and former education advisor to President Bill Clinton. "The debate is scrambled enough that the labels don't apply."

This week, the Bush tour is making a pit stop in Washington D.C.

The event: An education summit sponsored by his Foundation for Excellence in Education, which Bush formed after leaving office in 2007. Big-name wonks and policy makers from around the country are on hand, digesting panel discussions on everything from teacher quality to national standards.

Education should be more like milk, Bush told them Thursday. It's all about options.

"You can get flavored milk — chocolate, strawberry or vanilla — that doesn't even taste like milk," he said. "Most of the time, there is a whole other refrigerator case dedicated to milk alternatives – like soy milk, almond milk and rice milk. They even make milk for people who can't drink milk."

"Who would have ever thought you could improve upon milk? Yet, freedom, innovation and competition found a way."

Attendees are hearing plenty about Florida.

National kudos for the Florida Virtual School. A No. 10 ranking from Education Week.

But odds are, they're not hearing as much about Florida's graduation rates, which are still among the worst, according to several studies. Or about average scores on the ACT college entrance exam that put Florida at No. 48.

"If you were looking at a state that had done well in education, you wouldn't look at Florida," said Bob Schaeffer, a Florida resident and public education director for FairTest, a national group critical of standardized testing. "Florida is not doing better across the board."

But looking at Florida is exactly what states like Indiana and Arizona are doing. In fact, in coming months, both will take a serious look at adopting a Florida-style school grading system.

Both states have Republican governors and conservative think tanks that have hyped Bush's vision of reform. So it's no surprise he got warm receptions when he visited them last month. But supporters in both states also say the Florida results are compelling.

In 1994, Indiana fourth graders were 15 points ahead of their Florida peers on the reading portion of the National Assessment of Educational Progress, better known as the "nation's report card." By 2007, they were two points behind.

"While Florida has gained on everybody, Indiana has been stagnant," said Cam Savage, spokesman for the Indiana Department of Education.

Adams, the Arizona House Speaker and a Republican, pointed to Florida's progress on Advanced Placement tests for high school students. Florida is among the top states in both participation and passage rates.

"You can't argue with the results over, gosh, a 10-year period of time," Adams said.

The response from critics: Florida? Seriously?

Indiana state Rep. Gregory Porter, a Democrat who chairs the House education committee, says what he's heard about Florida is mostly confined to vouchers and virtual schools. "It's never crossed my mind" that Florida could be a model for student achievement, he said.

Porter said until he digs more deeply into the data, he'll remain skeptical.

On the education front, Bush has nothing but praise for President Barack Obama and his education secretary, Arne Duncan.

Obama has spoken favorably about charter schools. He has talked tough about incompetent teachers.

Meanwhile, it's widely assumed that Florida is a top contender for a piece of Duncan's $4.35 billion Race to the Top fund — designed to reward states that are pushing the envelope on reform — because its policies mesh so well with the secretary's agenda.

"It seems to me they're proposing more accountability, more choice, higher expectations," Bush said. "That's all great."

He'll keep pushing that agenda on the road, Bush said. And maybe not alone.

The Rev. Al Sharpton emailed him the other day, inviting him to a joint appearance with Sharpton, Duncan and former House Speaker Newt > Gingrich.

Bush said if his schedule permits, he'll be there. /education/k12/jeb-bush- hits-the-road-talking-education-and-pitching-floridas- cocktail-of/1042598# 


Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

5 + 5 =