November 5, 2014: Chicago Teachers Union to face most explosive House of Delegates meeting since the months before the Chicago Teachers Strike of 2012

Having already surrendered a good deal of its political credibility by the work that was done at the annual LEAD dinner on October 31, 2014, the leadership of the Chicago Teachers Union is facing a major debate on November 5, 2014, when its 800-member House of Delegates meets. The behind-closed-doors decision by a handful of members of the staff of the Chicago Teachers Union to engineer what I've been reporting as a coup d'etat on behalf of the mayoral candidacy of Cook County Commissioner Jesus Chuy Garcia has backfired in an almost unprecedented way, resulting in the union's facing some of the most serious challenges in its recent history as the union delegates assemble for their monthly meeting on November 5, 2014,

Mayoral candidate Bob Fioretti is hosting a major party on November 5, 2014, the same time that the Chicago Teachers Union House of Delegates is meeting. While a faction of the union's leadership continues to try and railroad through an endorsement of Jesus Chuy Garcia by the CTU even before the candidates' nominating petitions are in, a growing number of the union's members and delegates, still learning what happened during the week before Halloween, are working for form a "Teachers for Fioretti" committee. By late in the day on Monday, November 3, while the meeting of the union's executive board was still in progress, the email and phone lines linking union members across Chicago were blazing with discussions and debates after more and more members learned that the NEAD dinner on Halloween (October 31, 2014) had been turned into a mayoral campaign rally on behalf of Garcia, even as one of the most prominent candidates already in the race, Second Ward Alderman Bob Fioretti, sat with colleagues from the City Council "Progressive Caucus" at one of two tables ($500 per table) that Fioretti and his colleagues had purchased. Even those union members who might have considered a honest plea on behalf of the Garcia campaign were angered by the way in which the night was handled.

"QWe've destroyed our credibility," said one union staff member who asked to remain anonymous because the pressures on the union's workers to show "unity" has been more and more intense over the past week. "Bob Fioretti has stood by the teachers and the CTU for years, while Chuyy has been invisible most of the time. The disgraceful treatment of Fioretti can't be escaped."

In the face of escalating attacks on the public schools and the CTU by the administration of Mayor Rahm Emanuel since Emanuel became mayor in May 2011, Fiorett and a handful of others have [publicly supported the public schools -- and the CTU. The majority of members of the City Council either kept silent during the 2012 strike or spoke in public against the teachers, while Fiorett and his small number of colleagues stood with the teachers, even to the point of joining the union's picket lines.

Although the appearance at the LESD dinner was that the union was backing Garcia, it became clear that the backing was limited to a handful of union staff members and the union's president-one-leave Karen Lewis, who is fighting a "serious illness." Because CTU political support goes through a series of increasingly broad based democratic procedures before it becomes the position of the union, the unexpected push for Garcia on October 31 caught most veteran union activists by surprise.

Illinois Governor Pat Quinn speaks to the LEAD dinner on October 31, 2014 while CTU organizer staff member Brandon Johnson looks on. Substance photo by Sharon Schmidt.As this is being written, the CTU Executive Board is meeting at the union's downtown headquarters. The Executive Board consists of roughly 46 people, led by the union's elected officers. Each "functional group" within the union elects one "functional vice president" for every 1,000 union members. For example, the city's high school teachers, who have roughly 6,000 teacher members, elect six members to the Executive Board.

The Executive Board discusses the major issues facing the union on Monday before the union's House of Delegates meetings. For November 2014, the Executive Board meets on November 3 and the House of Delegates on November 5. Currently, there are more than 800 members elected to the House of Delegates. According to the union's constitution and by laws, no political endorsements may be made on behalf of the union except when approved by the House of Delegates. After a controversial appeal by Illinois Governor Pat Quinn at the unioni's June 4 meeting, the union's House of Delegates voted at its September 2014 meeting to endorse Quinn (over the objections of this reporter, who is a delegate).

That was the process as it existed -- and has existed for almost 100 years -- in the Chicago Teachers Union. But when the members arrived at Plumbers Hall for the annual LeAD dinner on October 31, 2014, they discovered that union staff members were distributing nominating petitons for Garcia even though the union's delegates barely knew who Garcia was -- and no HOD meeting had been asked to provide him with CTU support. The main candidate who was scheduled to speak at the LEAD was Governor Quinn, but his speech, originally announced as the "keynote", was pushed back by a speech by Jesus Garcia.

Other controversial things happened just before and during the LEAD. More than 1,000 union activists, each of whom had paid $50 for the corned beef and cabbage dinner, were made to wait until nearly eight o'clock while the speeches were made. A second program has also been quickly created and distributed with the orgiinal printed program at the last minute, making sure that a biography of Garcia was included along with biographies with the others featured speakers -- AFT President Randi Weingarten, Governor Pat Quinn, and Congressman Danny Davis.

The two major politicians who were disrespected the most at LEAD were the governor of one of the largest states in the USA, who arrived to discover that he was no longer keynote, and the Second Ward alderman, who arrived to discover that someone at the union had already decided that the candidacy of Bob Fioretti (who has already gathered his signatures to get on the ballot in the February municipal elections).


November 4, 2014 at 1:04 PM

By: Amy Gooden

Union Leadership

C.T.U. leadership should not be surprised at the response they are getting from the membership with regards to the LEAD dinner as well as the pre-delegate meeting endorsement of Mr. Garcia.

In my opinion, neither Governor Quinn,Mr. Rauner or their running mates give a d a m n about public education or schools, teachers(especially members of the Union),or students. Therefore, the C. T. U. endorsement of Mr. Quinn is like picking the devil you know versus the one you do not.

These candidates have gone to black ministers and beguiled them to sell their political agenda to their congregations. Once again it is presumed that black people are sheep. Control of black clergy comes from slavery.

However, there is the issue of protocol. How and why did Mr. Jesus "Chuy" Garcia become the keynote speaker? Mr. Quinn is still the Governor. Educators should never have participated in this social gaffe.

Mr. Garcia just threw his hat in the ring. However, Alderman Fioretti has always spoken up for educators along with other progressives. Why has Mrs. Lewis endorsed ANYONE before the meeting of the delegates? I respect her. However,without any information she is privy to, her endorsement seems premature and presumptuous.

A lawsuit was filed by C. T. U. Regarding the targeting of certain schools for turnaround and the reduction almost to extinction of black, veteran teachers. I totally support the Union`s stand.

However, what about a lawsuit for teachers (in some cases Union delegates)who were unfairly rated as unsatisfactory or given an E-3 ( or Union delegates) due to some Principals abusing their power and putting their personal feelings before their professional judgement?

Union leaders need to recognize that thousands of teachers have lost their jobs. Contract negotiations are in progress and there is going to be a strike if another contract like the current one is proposed to membership. This contract has got more holes than Swiss cheese!.

For example,when the contract was negotiated per pupil spending was not in place. Therefore, even though the Union successfully negotiated for teachers with lowered ratings to be able to apply for jobs it is almost to no avail. Principals cannot afford veteran teachers with a limited budget.Now subs are being used to take the place of teachers who have reapplied thru TALEO and can't get hired because there is no money to pay them. Other teachers are being asked to cover classes. Some students do not have an assigned teacher after ten weeks!

Is there anyone in the Union responsible for monitoring the hiring process to make sure that displaced teachers are even being considered for positions as stipulated in the contract?

C.T.U. needs to get some serious legal support and play hardball. They also need to recognize that some of those people who are unemployed will not be standing on a picket line next fall. Leadership should not also take for granted the vote for the C.O.R.E. slate next election.

C.T.U. leadership do not forget to respect your membership. They are ready,United and strong. Just do not take them for granted.

November 5, 2014 at 1:59 AM

By: Rodney L. Pruitt

CTU Needs Turnaround

CTU turned its back on its black teachers years ago. CPS stalled on rehiring these teachers in any capacity as many served as substitutes unable to make ends meet. Black teachers did not only lose their jobs with the past closing of 50 schools. Black male teachers were totally ignored by both entities. The remaining numbers of black teachers is a disgrace. Nothing will come of the CTU legal smokescreen or the actions of its longtime cheerleaders. Currently with the election of our new governor, the rest of us will disappear. No longer do I have sympathy for CTU. This body continued to take our money (dues) while doing nothing to fight for us. Thank you House of Delegates. I wondered how long it would take for you to see what has been in front of your face for years. You have estranged your membership. Maybe you thought CTU leadership was actually fighting for your interests.The strike is now in the past. What next?

November 5, 2014 at 7:15 AM

By: Roger L. Washington


Lets Hope and pray for the best Chicago!

November 5, 2014 at 7:18 AM

By: Roger L Washington

Get Ready!

Get Ready for Fioretti!

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

4 + 5 =