Sections:

Article

OPT OUT NEWS: Explosion of resistance to ISAT testing program grows as Drummond Elementary teachers vote to boycott the testing program that begins Monday

Surrounded by parents, students, fellow teachers and reporters, teachers from Chicago's Drummond Elementary School proudly announced on the afternoon of February 28, 2014, that they were joining their fellow teachers at Saucedo Elementary School in boycotting the ISAT (Illinois Standards Assessment Tests) testing program. The ISAT is scheduled to begin the first school day of March -- March 3, 2014 -- in all Chicago elementary schools.

Teachers and parents at Chicago's Drummond Elementary School at the February 28 press conference at which they announced that the majority of teachers at Drummond were boycotting the administration of the ISAT tests. Left to right above, Anne Carlson (Drummond teacher), Jesse Sharkey (Vice President, Chicago Teachers Union), Juan Gonzalez (Drummond teacher), Mary Zerkel (Drummond parent), and Cassie Creswell, a parent leader of the group "More Than A Score." Substance photo by Sharon Schmidt.The announcement confirmed that a majority of Drummond 3rd through 8th grade teachers had voted to boycott the ISAT in March 2014. At the press conference in front of the school, the teachers were joined by parents, students, community leaders, and union officials who support their decision.

The Drummond teachers join teachers from Maria Saucedo Elementary School, who voted earlier to boycott the tests. Both Drummond and Saucedo are among the highest ranked CPS elementary schools. Despite the fact that the ISAT tests are being ended by the state of Illinois, Chicago Public Schools officials have scheduled ten full school days for the ISAT and have threatened children, parents, principals and teachers who oppose the waste of time exemplified by the program.

In addition to the schools that have announced the boycott, hundreds of teachers have been informing parents and children that they have the right to refuse to take the ISAT (and other so-called "standardized" tests) since the beginning of February. The organizing against the over-testing has been done by several parents and community groups, including "More Than A Score," a Chicago group, and by the Caucus Of Rank and file Educators (CORE), the caucus that leads the Chicago Teachers Union. Union officers including President Karen Lewis and Vice President Jesse Sharkey have also spoken out public in support of the opt outs and boycotts.

The Drummond teachers told the large number of reporters who came to the school that they were well aware that they may face serious professional consequences when they begin their actual act of conscientious objection on Monday, March 3. Threats from CPS administrators have been published in the press and also conveyed through the school system's crumbling administrative infrastructure. Throughout the week, Substance has been receiving reports that principals have been ordered to threaten teachers and parents with dire consequences if they refuse to take or administer the ISAT, despite the fact that the test is being ended by the State of Illinois.

Drummond teacher Anne Carlson hugs a supportive student at the February 28, 2014 press conference.In a February 27 email, the CPS "Chief Executive Officer" Barbara Byrd Bennett said that she wanted the teachers to lose their Illinois teaching licenses if they refuse to administer the tests when ordered to do so. At a hastily called "Webinar" for principals across the city, CPS officials went over a series of threats against children, parents, teachers and principals in the face of the growing boycott of the ISAT in Chicago. Confused and often illegal threats had been coming out of CPS administration for more than two weeks, since the opt out movement "Ice the ISAT" began expanding among parents and children, with accompanying attempts by officials in the nation's third largest school system to muzzle school workers and gag reporters who have been trying to cover the stories that have been breaking new every day. [See related "First Amendment? Not In Chicago Public Schools!" story at substancenews.net thttp://www.substancenews.net/articles.php?page=4848§ion=Article].

MORE THAN A SCORE STATEMENT BY CASSIE CRESSWELL BELOW HERE:

Statement given today at press conference with Drummond teachers who boycotted the test:

Cassie Creswell of More Than A Score speaking to reporters during the February 28, 2014 press conference at Drummond Elementary School in Chicago. Substance photo by Sharon Schmidt.I am speaking on behalf of More Than A Score, a coalition of Chicago parents, teachers, and students fighting against the misuse and overuse of standardized testing in the Chicago Public Schools.

We are here in support of the teachers here at Drummond and at Saucedo school who have refused to administer the ISAT. We fully encourage any parents who wish to opt their students out of the test to do so.

However, we are also here because we are very concerned about the ethical treatment of children and families who have opted out of the ISAT.

A webinar went to all CPS principals yesterday telling them to place the test in front of all children and read test directions verbatim to all children, even if their parents have opted them out of this test.

This comes after CPS CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett sent two letters to parents telling them they have the right to opt out, and after years of CPS allowing children to opt out of the ISAT with no such treatment.

It is unclear where directives are coming from regarding this move, but pushing a policy of forcing children to refuse a test is wrong.

Putting children in a position that requires disobeying their teacherthe adult that their parents entrust them into the care of every school dayis wrongheaded and abusive.

Pressuring children, some as young as eight years old, to participate in activities against their parent or guardians wishes is unethical and immoral.

The argument that schools must administer the test because it is the law does not trump a parents decision of whats best for their child. There has been a law in Illinois that children in elementary schools should get daily PE classes, but that law has been ignored by CPS officials for decades. There are federal laws are supposed to protect kids who require medical or special education services at school, and there are children in this district who are not getting those services.

CPS has said that the district may risk losing Title I funding due to testing opt outs. There is no evidence that this is the case. We have reviewed the US Code and the Code of Federal Regulations and found no references to automatic funding cuts for failure to make Adequate Yearly Progress. This district has not made AYP since at least 2005. Only 64 CPS schools made AYP last year. If there were any cuts, theyve happened already.

CPS is wrong when it says that it is the law to put a test in front of a child whose parent or legal guardian has refused the test on their behalf.

During the ISAT testing window, we fully expect principals and teachersthe adults whom we entrust our childrens care to every day of the school yearto treat our children with kindness, to allow them to engage in alternative quiet activities during the test, and to respect our wishes as parents and guardians to direct our childrens education.

All parents should demand nothing less.



Comments:

March 1, 2014 at 9:46 AM

By: Sharon Schmidt

IFT support from Drummond, Saucedo

From Progress Illinois:

The Illinois Federation of Teachers has also voiced their support for educators who refuse to administer the ISAT, including the more than 40 teachers at Saucedo that voted unanimously against giving their students the test.

"Facing the threat of discipline or termination, these brave teachers are standing up for what they believe is best for their students, no matter the personal consequences. It is nothing short of a profile in courage, said President of the Illinois Federation of Teachers Dan Montgomery in a statement. The preparation and administration of this test brings teaching to a halt and robs students of valuable time to learn. The ISAT is not appropriately aligned to curriculum and forces educators to teach to an unnecessary test that is defunct and has absolutely no practical use. This is merely testing for testings sake, and we encourage parents to work with their teachers to opt out. We also strongly encourage CPS to reconsider their plans to punish teachers for doing the right thing. IFT members around the state salute and stand with these teachers and parents as they stand up for their students.

http://progressillinois.com/quick-hits/content/2014/02/27/battle-brewing-between-cps-teachers-over-isat

March 1, 2014 at 10:53 AM

By: George N. Schmidt

'Vedder' was a troll

The email from the Troll who was calling himself "Eddie Vedder" has been deleted from Substance comments. Our policy is to email anyone about whom we are suspicious about when we hear from them for the first time. We also DELETE anyone who publishes using anonymous and pseudo-nonymous stuff. We police the site every night. Anyone who wishes to post using his or her own name is free to make a comment, but trollacious attacks, anonymous, and pseudo-nonymous stuff is deleted.

March 1, 2014 at 1:28 PM

By: Kati Gilson, NBCT

testing out of control

It's time to go after the early childhood testing. Four standardized assessments in preschool is ridiculous. Weeks are spent testing 3 & 4 year olds individually. Time that would be better spent engaging them in minds-on hands-on activities all the while working on developing the social skills

they so desperately need.

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at substancenews.net. We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

4 + 1 =