SUBSCRIPT: 'If she can mention West Virginia and Ohio she can tell 1.5 million members to support Chicago now!'... Is AFT president Randi Weingarten Rahm's secret hope for the sellout?

One week after a controversial article in the Chicago Sun-Times declared that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel would intervene in contract negotiations between the Chicago Public Schools and the Chicago Teachers Union, a stunning "Labor Day Message" from Randi Weingarten, President of the American Federation of Teachers, has many Chicago teachers wondering whether Weingarten has been selected to cut a deal on behalf of Rahm Emanuel — and against the members of the CTU, the most militant of the K-12 locals in the AFT.

AFT President Randi Weingarten, who never was really a New York City public school teacher, hugging former Chicago chemistry teacher (and CTU President) Karen Lewis on stage at the May 23, 2012, CTU rally inside the Auditorium Theatre. Substance photo by Graham Hill.The increasing suspicion about Randi's work not only comes from her history (she was completely committed to the programs of former CTU President Marilyn Stewart and promoted them enormously during the 2008 AFT convention which was held in Chicago), but also from current events. Randi's "Labor Day Message" communicated to all AFT members via email on August 31, 2012 did not mention the Chicago struggle, even though Randi was in Chicago for May 23 and has had a representative at the CTU offices for several months. Additionally, the AFT convention passed a Special Order of Business pledging support for Chicago and other locals under attack. While many delegates to the convention were suspicious at the time, the "Labor Day Message" confirms those suspicions.

Below is that message, ignoring Chicago:

Dear [AFT MEMBER] Thank you for your work, your dedication and your commitment to the children and people you serve.

Labor Day means many things to many people—back to school, the end of summer, a needed respite from the daily grind. For us, as working people and union members, Labor Day stands for something special and profound.

It’s a day to honor the deep commitment each of us has to serve the children we teach, the families we heal and the communities we love. It’s a day to reflect on the values we hold dear—that every American should have access to a good job that can support a family, with access to affordable healthcare; that every child should be able to attend a high-quality public school in their neighborhood; that college should not be a luxury for the few but should be affordable for all; and that we should be able to retire with dignity after a lifetime of hard work, without worrying that we’ll be a burden to our loved ones.

Working people built this country — we did it together — brick by brick, school by school, town by town. Through these collective efforts, we built the middle class, each generation did a little better than the one before, we advanced the ideals of equality and justice, and we expanded opportunity for all.

The work you do builds on this foundation. Your work has value. It should be respected and honored, not just on Labor Day but every day.

Too many of us feel that the American dream we built is slipping further and further away. And with just 7 percent of our private sector colleagues in unions, we have seen growing wealth and wage inequality, and as a result, growing frustration and angst. At the same time, too many politicians and elites demean and disrespect our work while budget cuts and calls for austerity make it harder to provide high-quality services.

And no wonder. An unholy alliance of corporate interests and politicians — intent on slashing budgets and then blaming us for the harmful results, while at the same time finding ways to finance tax cuts for wealthy donors — continue to double down on efforts to polarize and divide us: parent against teacher, union member against nonunion member. Because if we stand divided, they stand to profit.

This is our new normal.

And our union is meeting this moment with a new vision of unionism: solution-driven unionism. It’s an approach that is relevant and appropriate to the 21st century. An approach that is creative and visionary. An approach that advances solutions that unite the people we represent and those we serve—our students, our families and our communities.

We must bring people together around agendas that serve all kids, all workers and all communities—to restore the middle class, strengthen our public schools, and invest in, not destabilize, communities.

We must counter polarization and anger with ideas and innovation. It’s what AFT members and leaders are focused on across the nation.

It’s why we’re advancing a Quality Education Agenda that offers specific proposals to create a first-class public education system for all children in America. And why we are attacking the fixation on testing in this country with a grass-roots campaign to get back to teaching and learning.

It’s why we worked with an innovative corporation to develop a digital filing cabinet of lesson plans and ideas for teachers called Share My Lesson. It’s a commonsense solution to help teachers who are being asked to do so much more with diminishing resources and without the supports they need.

It’s why we are mitigating the impact that poverty and other out-of-school factors have on students in places like Cincinnati, by partnering with the community to offer health and mental health services, meal programs, tutoring, counseling, after-school programs and other wraparound services.

It’s why in one of America’s very poorest regions, we are leading a coalition of businesses, community groups and educators to completely transform the educational and economic opportunities available to children and families in McDowell County, W.Va.

It’s what we were able to accomplish this past year in Ohio—linking with the community to stop Gov. John Kasich’s efforts to strip working people of their voice.

Because when we—the dedicated members of the American Federation of Teachers and other union members—propose solutions, it’s harder to demonize us, harder to cut vital services, and harder to divide us from the people we serve.

The best solutions come from you. It is your ideas that will strengthen our schools, hospitals and communities. Just as with the generations before us, it is your work and commitment that will propel economic and educational opportunity and social justice. Visit to share your solutions and ideas.

Our ability to advance these solutions depends on electing leaders who believe in public education as a pathway to our future; who believe that public employees and healthcare professionals provide essential services and must be treated fairly; and who believe that working people and their families are entitled to a voice in their destiny and a pathway to fairness, dignity and respect. The November elections will determine the future of our nation; this is a defining moment to stand up for our values and our vision for America.

I know that, together, we can turn a time of frustration and uncertainty into a time of action and promise.

I thank you for the work you do each and every day—through good times and bad—to serve your communities and imagine a better future for our nation. That is solution-driven unionism. And together we can turn our values into reality.

Have a safe and happy Labor Day. In unity,

Randi Weingarten

AFT President


September 1, 2012 at 7:04 PM

By: Margaret Wilson



How can you lead the AFT without supporting the struggles of Chicago teachers. We are Local 1 for a reason. We were the first teachers in the country to band together and become certified under the AFT. We led many militant actions here in Chicago and supported our colleagues throughout the country and even in Canada. I remember going to Canada with some of my colleagues to support the teachers there in a prolonged strike. Don't turn your backs on us now We all need each other especially today.

September 7, 2012 at 10:28 AM

By: Ann Cata

AFT must support CTU

Randi and the AFT better support the CTU.

If they do not support our efforts for a fair contract, then all of the other UNIONS in the AFT MUST!!!

If it wasn't for Unions, there would be no holiday pay, overtime, benefits, the list goes on and on. Not just for Unions but all working persons.

Randi be a stronger AFT leader and promote the CTU and assist LOCAL 1.


September 7, 2012 at 8:31 PM

By: Anthony Smith

Randi is a traitor to us all

Randi needs to step down immediately as a gesture of understanding that she is not up to the job of representing us.

Randi needs to respect that we stand for fairness and equality. When she visited and told us that she was with us and that she would be with us whenever we needed her (May 23, 2012 rally) she lied.

It is okay if she wants to represent the 1%. She is entitled to do that. BUT she is not entitled to claim that she represents our best interests when it is evident she does not.

Randi, Please step down, NOW!

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

1 + 4 =