Sections:

Chicago Tonight continues blacklist against George Schmidt, lies to CTU about reasons for canceling him

WTTW Chicago Tonight lied to the CTU about why they were canceling George Schmidt from their CPS budget segment. Production assistant Shanika Gunaratna (above with Chicago Teachers Union Vice President Jesse Sharkey and CTU budget consultant George N. Schmidt) told CTU's communication director Stephanie Gadlin that CPS Chief Administrative Officer Tim Cawley didn't want to appear with Schmidt. Cawley confirmed that that was a lie, and that he had "nothing to do with it." Substance photo by Sharon Schmidt.Chicago Tonight and the Chicago Teachers Union planned for CTU budget consultant George Schmidt to appear on Chicago Tonight on July 10 to discuss the CPS budget with CPS Chief Administrative Officer Tim Cawley. See Substance reporter George Schmidt to be on public TV 'Chicago Tonight' show at 7 p.m. July 10

However, on the afternoon of July 10, after interviewing Schmidt on the phone, Chicago Tonight assistant Shanika Gunaratna called the CTU and told Stephanie Gadlin, CTU Communications Director, that Schmidt was cancelled from the segment.

"She called and said there was a problem with George," Gadlin told Substance. "She said 'Tim Cawley doesn't want to do the show with George. Can we have (CTU VP) Jesse Sharkey instead?'"

Gadlin also told Substance that Gunaratna didn't want to inform Schmidt that Chicago Tonight was canceling his appearance.

"She said, 'Can you call George and tell him?'" Gadlin told Substance. "I said, 'No, you have to do that.'"

Substance contacted Cawley's office that afternoon and later confirmed with him in person at WTTW that evening that he had nothing to do with the decision.

"I had nothing to do with it," Cawley told Substance.

Schmidt went into the WTTW studios with Sharkey before the segment was to be filmed. The following dialogue took place in the meeting room shown in the picture. This reporter, who showed her press pass and was taking notes, also tape recorded the exchange.

Schmidt: Who cancelled me?

Gunaratna: I cancelled you. I cancelled you.

Schmidt: Why did you cancel me?

Gunaratna: That’s our editorial decision. You didn’t fit into the balance of our panel. You can’t just show up after you have been cancelled, sir.

Schmidt: This is a significant story. The Chicago Teachers Union asked me to be here. That ‘s the balance of the panel. And we just want to know who decided besides you, because I just don’t think you are at the rank to make that decision. And what’s your last name, by the way, since we’re on the record?

Gunaratna didn’t respond. She excused herself and brought in Jay Smith, a Chicago Tonight production assistant, who said canceling Schmidt was "an internal decision we made." When pressed, he said the decision was made by he and Gunaratha and Mary Field, the Executive Producer of Chicago Tonight.

When questioned about Gunaratna's lie to the CTU about Cawley not wanting to be on the show with Schmidt, Smith also obfuscated.

"[CPS] implied that," Smith said. "They may not have said it directly."

When this reporter asked Gunaratna about her lie she first only shook her head. After I questioned her again, she refused to explain her lie.

"I have no comment to that," Gunaratna said.

George Schmidt was asked by officials of the Chicago Teachers Union to be on the show representing the union. He is currently a retired CTU member and delegate representing retired teachers, as well as a reporter for Substance and a consultant on budget and other matters for the CTU. In 1988, Schmidt was part of the "budget transition team"

Since then, he has organized studies of the CPS budget and participated in the annual CPS budget hearings, both as giving testimony and as a reporter, for "decades." During the past four years, he had helped organize and train a group of researchers who have followed the CPS budget in detail, with studies ranging from the annual CAFR (the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report) to the Position Files and W-2 files that show CPS spending.

George Schmidt cancelled another scheduled activity to prepare for the WTTW show.

"I used to do these regularly," Schmidt said, "back in the 1980s and early 1990s, but then WTTW seemed to find my research, experience and knowledge less interesting than those who have since been on the show."



Comments:

July 11, 2012 at 9:52 AM

By: Larry MacDonald

Linda Lenz remove the pacifier.

How can Lenz conclude, after her extensive experience covering the Public Schools in Chicago, that she doesn't know who is telling the truth. What a tool. Duh?

Journalist — turn in that GUMBALL!

Sorry, you got cut from the discussion. It would have been infinitely more interesting. SOS — and I do mean Save our Schools.

Larry

Tuckasegee, NC

July 11, 2012 at 11:20 AM

By: Anthony Smith

WTTW should be ASHAMED of its behavior!

WTTW should be ASHAMED of its behavior!

WTTW's Chicago Tonight, (and I thought this was a Public News station), refusing to allow George Schmidt, the Chicago Teachers Union chosen spokesperson, to speak is CENSORSHIP!

What are you afraid of WTTW???

I used to believe that WTTW's Chicago Tonight was an honorable institution and dealt respectfully with political and social topics.

After the past year of watching, culminating in the July 1oth show where the management decided to block George Schmidt from being on the air, I have to say that I believe WTTW is bought and paid for by the very power brokers who clearly wish to destroy Unions, and with them the middle class.

I would ask WTTW to do the right and fair thing and ask George to come on and offer his political, social, and financial perspective regarding the School system in Chicago.

If they were to do that I would be inclined to continue watching Chicago Tonight and offering a monetary pledge.

Otherwise I am inclined to avoid watching WTTW's Chicago Tonight and consider it a mouthpiece for those with political and financial clout!

Perhaps we could request a petition drive, complete with t-shirts that say: "WTTW, Let George Speak!"

Thank you George for your lifetime of hard work and dedication to the cause of fairness, truth, and doing what is right!

Best wishes,

Anthony Smith

July 11, 2012 at 12:58 PM

By: Sue Furman

Chicago Tonight is becoming FOX

My husband and I wrote a letter withdrawing our membership support of WTTW after the horrible Chicago Tonight interview where they skewered Karen Lewis about "taking a strike vote". They couldn't even figure out that the authorization vote wasn't a "vote to go out on strike". We received a semi-form letter informing us that we should continue to watch Chicago Tonight so that we could witness all the "hard hitting, tough questions" they ask of Mayor Emanuel and Mr. Brizard. Yeah, right. Don't think I'll be doing that anytime soon. I'm transferring my PBS support over to WYCC.

July 11, 2012 at 6:03 PM

By: Sarah Loftus

Chg tonite

Let's talk about the content on the show:

Jesse did a great job.

When pressed on CPS spending more on charters instead of neighborhood schools, Cawley said something to the effect that CPS loves neighborhood schools, "and when they fail..." get that "and when they fail..." "and when they fail..." not if but when, so it seems, as we have known for nearly 20 years, that CPS has set in motion policies to insure that these schools will fail.

L Lenz did say she didn't know who to believe which is better than her usual total support of CPS.

July 12, 2012 at 8:36 AM

By: John Stewart Whitfield Cutler

An effort to silence reporting?

The questions are why was George Schmidt censored, and why did they lie?

Could any comparisons be drawn from this New York times headline this morning, given the recent sabotage of Substance?

Attacks on Mexican Papers Underline Peril to Journalists, by RANDAL C. ARCHIBALD

Two newspapers in Northern Mexico have come under attack by gunfire and grenades this week, in what both called an effort to silence reporting on criminal groups.

No war but class war folks. Do we have our act together? John

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at substancenews.net. We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

1 + 2 =