Group gave $3.1 million to union busting via the 'Renaissance Schools Fund'... CME says 'Thank You, Chicago' by reducing charitable giving, cutting off charter schools

[Editor's Note: Less than a week after CME Group (that's the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and related betting parlors) got a major tax break from the State of Illinois (which is claiming it can't afford to pay back all the money that's been taken from teacher retirement funds), CME group announced, just in time for the holidays, that it will be a bleak Christmas for many Chicago area schools. This includes charter schools, which have been major recipients of CME charity. The report from Reuters is below].

Reuters Exclusive: CME Trust's charity grants halt on MF failure, December 18, 2011. By Ann Saphir

CHICAGO (Reuters) - CME Group Inc, which has given $22 million to Chicago-area schools and charities over the past five years, has stopped making grants through its main foundation, citing the collapse of MF Global Holdings Inc.

DECEMBER 14, 2011. Phyllis Lockett (above left) didn't have to wait in line at 5 a.m. to speak to the Chicago Board of Education meeting on December 14, 2011. She was brought up to the front and allowed to speak after the Board members returned from the "Great Scurrying" and held a truncated version of their monthly meeting behind a phalanx of security. When the decision to allow Lockett to speak was challenged by Noreen Gutekanst, Board President David Vitale responded to the question "Why is she being allowed to speak?" with an abrupt: "Because I said so, that's why" (or something to that imperious affect). Lockett is Chief Executive Officer of New Schools for Chicago, which pours corporate millions into anti-union charter schools, and is a privileged member of the "one percent" that sets CPS policy. Above, Locket works her Blackberry in the back of the December 14, 2011 Board meeting, while Andrew Broy of the "Illinois Network of Charter Schools stands by. Substance photo by George N. Schmidt.Investigators are still searching for hundreds of millions of dollars of customer funds that CME says were improperly siphoned off in the brokerage's final days to plug its escalating liquidity needs.

Last month, the exchange operator said it would give former MF Global customers the entire $50 million held by CME Trust, which was originally designed to help traders caught out by a broker default but that in recent years has been a mainstay of the CME's charitable giving.

"CME Group will continue to honor some previous Trust commitments going forward - even after the $50 million is paid out," CME spokeswoman Laurie Bischel said. "Though the CME Trust will be used to help customers of MF Global, CME Group remains committed to our communities and will continue to provide support to charitable organizations as possible through our other programs and corporate foundations."

She declined to specify the overall level of future grants and it is unclear if other programs could partially or fully make up the loss of the Trust's contributions. CME charitable giving has gone up and down through the years.

CME Trust was established in 1969 to provide financial assistance to customers if a brokerage became insolvent.

Federal rules requiring brokers to keep client money separate from their own made the prospect of customers actually losing money in a broker default seem so remote that the CME's board in 2005 voted to turn the Trust into a charitable foundation.

In 2008, after giving millions of dollars to local institutions, the Trust launched CME Group Foundation with a $16 million grant, and pledged to make annual donations to support the Foundation's grant-making. The Foundation has become the exchange operator's biggest charitable giver, doling out more than $6 million last year alone.

But in the early hours of October 31, the day MF Global filed for bankruptcy, the brokers' executives made what regulators have since said was a shocking disclosure - that money had been moved from customer accounts to the firm's accounts, and was now missing.

In mid-November, CME's board voted to turn CME Trust back to its original purpose.

It is now clear that decision will mean less money for Chicago-area universities, charter schools and institutions aimed at early childhood education, a look at CME Group Foundation's recent record of charitable giving shows.

"All new CME Group Foundation grant proposals will be put on hold until further notice," the Foundation now says on its website. "We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause grant applicants."

The news comes a day after CME won a months-long battle for a tax break from the state, which had hiked the corporate tax rate in January in an effort to plug a budget shortfall.

The legislation, signed by Illinois Governor Pat Quinn on Friday, will reduce CME's tax bill compared to what it was before the tax hike, shaving off about $77 million annually when it takes full effect in 2014.

CME operates the Chicago Board of Trade, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, and the New York Mercantile Exchange, and only its own customers will be eligible for reimbursements.

Funds would be paid out after the bankruptcy trustee determines the money is really gone. CME Executive Chairman Terrence Duffy this month estimated the shortfall at $700 million to $900 million.

Among the biggest beneficiaries of CME Group Foundation largess in recent years are the Renaissance Schools Fund [now known as "New Schools for Chicago" since Renaissance 2010 ended], which supports charter schools and has received $3.1 million since 2006; the University of Chicago, which has received $2.5 million since 2006; and the Erikson Institute, which specializes in early childhood education and has received $1.625 million.

Other big recipients include several Chicago-area universities, the Big Shoulders Fund and the Ounce of Prevention Fund, which focuses on early childhood intervention in at-risk populations.

"We have been assured that the CME Group Foundation will honor its existing multiyear commitment to the Ounce," a spokeswoman for the organization, which received a $1 million four-year grant this year, told Reuters.

The Foundation also supports dozens of charities with smaller grants funding pediatric medical and cardiovascular research, cancer care, and a variety of educational services.

Two smaller charitable arms, the CME Group Community Foundation and the CBOT Foundation, are not affected by the MF Global debacle. Their donations last year totaled just over $1 million.

All grants previously approved will be honored, CME Group Foundation said on its website.

(Reporting by Ann Saphir; Editing by Eric Walsh, Martin Howell)


Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

2 + 4 =