Vice President tells teachers Obama administration still loves us, says... Attacks on Public Workers Biggest Scam In American History

[originally published July 4th 2011]

Vice President Joe Biden in July 3, 2011 a speech to the more than 9000 delegates to the 2011 National Education Association Represenative Assembly in Chicago that teachers and other public workers are being scapegoated by Republicans and corporate America. The delegates, representing the 3.2 million members of the National Education Association, listened as Biden had harsh criticism for corporate interests and the legislators they back who attack those educators, the poor, and the American worker. He called the attacks on public workers and attempts to blame them for budget shortfalls now taking place nationwide, "one of the biggest scams in modern American history.

National Education Association President Dennis Van Roekel (center) and U.S. Vice President Joe Biden (right) go on stage at the NEA convention on July 3, 2011. Substance photo by John Kugler."Thank God for your unyielding belief that in the toughest of circumstances every child, every child, deserves a chance," Biden told the audience of nearly 9,000 people. "I just wish those folks who are attacking you now, I wish those folks who are trying to ascribe the blame for the worst recession America has had since the Great Depression knew you a little better."

NEA members' fight for their rights as workers, is "about our children," Biden said. "Your fight is about giving them the best chance." He later added, "because of you the American dream will grow faster and further than ever before."


Remarks for Vice President Joe Biden, National Education Association, Chicago, IL, July 3,2011

We all have something in common—you, me, Barack, Michelle — none of us would be in the positions we are today without the inspiration, love, and guidance of an educator.

Thank you for inviting me.

I know you have a lot of more business to conduct before this assembly ends.

So, let me get right to the point.

Dennis—I read your speech.

It was rhetorically good.

The Kennedy Expressway was shut down for a half hour on July 3, 2011, because of security concerns about Joe Biden's visit to the NEA convention. Security at the convention was equally tight, forcing thousands of NEA delegate (above) to wait in the longest lines ever. Substance photo by John Kugler.More importantly, it contained real insight that is not reflected in the public debate.

What’s more, there’s not a single thing you said that I disagree with.

Yesterday, you said: “I know of no family of means in America who would deny their own children preschool, child care, good nutrition, health care, and other opportunities, from soccer to music to dance to art. So, if a nation wants to remain strong and prosperous, why would we perpetuate a system that denies these opportunities for any child?”

Well, the answer, Dennis, is that the other team doesn’t think we can afford it, and they don’t think it’s a priority.

This new Republican party has a different philosophy.

I don’t think they really believe in public education, as we do.

Public education is as much about poverty, lack of health care, and unemployment, as it is about what goes on in the classroom.

To quote Dennis again, “part of the madness of this country is an economy that is out of balance”.

To the new Republican Party, it is madness by design. They don’t think it’s out of balance; they think it’s reestablishing balance.

They believe:

• A CEO making 260 times what their workers make is a honest reflection of their respective value.

• That one percent of wage earners controlling 24 percent of wealth will spur economic growth.

• That hedge fund managers making billions of income should paying a 15% tax rate while teachers making tens of thousands in income should pay 25% or more— because it will encourage investors to take risks for economic growth.

Dennis, as you said, you are under attack.

The Republican party has undertaken the most direct assault on labor not just in your lifetimes—but since the 1920s.

Our difference with the governors of Wisconsin and Ohio and Florida and Michigan... all over ... is much deeper than our differing philosophies on public education and educators.

Fundamentally, it is about the importance of community and the appropriate role of government.

So it should be no surprise that the same people who are pushing vouchers for schools are pushing vouchers to replace Medicare.

It should be no surprise that the same people who want to eliminate for the middle class a $10,000 tax credit for college tuition also want to lower tax rates for the top 1 percent who make millions.

It should be no surprise that the same people who opposed our effort to fund reconstruction of schools also opposed major investments infrastructure investment for highways, bridges, ports.

It should be no surprise that the same people who were against aid to states in the Recovery Act to allow them to keep 300,000 educators on the job had no problem aiding investment bankers on Wall Street.

It should be no surprise that the same people who oppose funding community colleges that are retraining workers for specific companies in America are for incentives for some of these same companies who ship jobs overseas.

It should be no surprise that those who oppose subsidizing after-school programs are for subsidizing oil companies to drill for oil.

It should be no surprise that the folks who want to cut school lunch and nutrition programs also vote against unemployment insurance and food stamps for the jobless.

It should be no surprise that the same people who want to slash funding medical and scientific research at our great universities also want to slash funding for innovation, for renewable energy, for new lithium-ion batteries.


This debate is about whether or not for America to succeed we need to provide the best education for all of our children—or for just some of our children.

Folks, I could go on and on and on ... but, in the end, it’s about more than education. It’s about social equality, economic opportunity, concentration of wealth.

It’s about not only what we are doing in education, but what we are doing to our country.

And, just look around the country ... Wisconsin, Ohio, Florida on and on and on.

All over the country, they’ve rejected good-faith offers by teachers and other public employees to sacrifice and do their part to help balance the state budget, and instead used the budget process to systematically erode the rights of public employees to collectively bargain.

Slashes in education spending. Reneging on teacher contracts. Mandating a decertification vote for any union involved in a teacher strike action. Limiting the issues public school employees can bargain over. Paycheck deception. Benefits slashed, wages cut.

All states are struggling from the impacts of a brutal recession. Yet, there is an organized effort to place the blame for budget shortfalls squarely on educators and other public workers.

This is a debate about a fundamental difference in vision our vision and their vision.

Look, folks—in these times of change, I am sure you haven’t loved everything we’ve done. We won’t agree on absolutely everything.

But you should not have doubt in your mind who’s on your side. Who’ll fight with you, and fight for you.

This administration stands for education, and with labor.

It’s about your fundamental right to collectively bargain about the environment in which you work, the size of your classroom, the mix of special education students in the classroom, after-school programs

It’s also about whether or not we will provide adequate preschool education,

It’s about whether or not we will have classroom sizes that allow a child to be recognized,

It’s about whether we will offer courses in math and science, introduce our children to art and music.

It’s about whether or not there will be adequate sports programs.

And it’s about whether we provide the educational and financial capabilities for every student who wants to go to college.

And, ultimately, it’s about whether America will retain its place in the world.

It’s a fact: more than half the jobs in the next decade will require a post-secondary education.

How can we expect to compete in the future without the best-prepared, best-educated workforce in the world?

And, how can we expect to do that without you?

People are starting to wake up to this, too—in Madison, in Columbus, all over. You are on the front lines of those battles.

You are teaching the next great engineer how to do arithmetic.

You are teaching the next great novelist how to write a sentence.

You are uncovering the next Mozart and unleashing the next Steve Jobs.

You are building generation after generation of hard-working Americans in all walks of life.., doctors, lawyers, architects, computer programmers, welders, business owners, artists, soldiers and, yes, educators.

In your classroom is the incubator of a new technology. A future scientific breakthrough. A medical discovery.

In your classroom is a future President of the United States.

And you all know what my wife knows—you never know where that child will come from. You never know whether that child comes from a rowhouse or a mansion, from the inner city or a farm.

But you know they will come form our children.

These are our children.

They’re not someone else children’s.

They’re America’s children.

They are the kite strings upon which our national ambitions are held aloft.

And, in the end, we will be judged by whether we’ve honored our obligation to them.

My favorite poet William Butler Yeats once wrote that:

Education is not the filling of a bucket, but the lighting of a fire.

We stand with you to keep that fire lit—and lit brightly—for Americans everywhere, for generations to come.

We stand with NEA because without you, the American dream will grow further and further out of reach for average Americans.

We stand with you because you stand with people who are struggling to get into the middle class, as well as your own members.

We stand with you--NEA—because, with you, we can and will restore the American Dream.

Thank you. May God bless you all. And may God protect our troops.

Biggest Scams in Modern History 070311

Biden different breed of cat 070311


July 4, 2011 at 11:49 AM

By: bob Busch

Smiling Faces

What a thing to say in Illinois if he really believes what he said all he has to do\rIs go see Arnie.This is unbelievable .\r

July 4, 2011 at 12:08 PM

By: Displaced Teacher

Not once...

...did he mention "Race to the Top". I wonder why!

July 4, 2011 at 12:19 PM

By: Rod Estvan

Won't Get Fooled Again

In many ways Vice President Binden’s speech and the NEA resolution on Secretary Duncan were part and parcel of the same theme. As the Vice President said “Look, folks—in these times of change, I am sure you haven’t loved everything we’ve done. We won’t agree on absolutely everything. But you should not have doubt in your mind who’s on your side. Who’ll fight with you, and fight for you. This administration stands for education, and with labor.”

Then we have the NEA resolution which goes after Secretary Duncan in isolation from President Obama, almost as if the Secretary of Education was not implementing exactly what President Obama wants and for that matter also what Mayor Emanuel also wants. Vice President Biden tells has the audacity to tell teachers meeting here in Chicago where SB 7 voted on and approved by a Democratic controlled Illinois State legislature that: “It’s about your fundamental right to collectively bargain about the environment in which you work, the size of your classroom, the mix of special education students in the classroom…”

Here a little secret, Vice President Binden was a long time supporter of the Democratic leadership council (DLC) that went out of business earlier this year (in 2005 Binden was given the Democratic Leadership Council's Harry S. Truman Award). If you look at that organization’s web page, which is still up, you will find an organization that was basically in agreement with the Gates Foundation on where US education needed to go today. Mayor Emanuel has been very close to the DLC and he is currently implementing policies consistent with the DLC perspective on education.

The rock song by the WHO titled “Won't Get Fooled Again” part of that song goes:

There's nothing in the street

Looks any different to me

And the slogans are replaced, by-the-bye

And the parting on the left

Is now the parting on the right

And the beards have all grown longer overnight

Maybe the next time a teacher’s union convention invites a Democratic Party big wig to make up and make nice they can play this song as an introduction.

Rod Estvan

July 7, 2011 at 9:12 PM

By: Nick Shafer

Who are you going to vote for then?

In football, when a team is backed up on their own 30 yard line and it is fourth down, the do not throw an interception because they are pissed at their coach. Nor do they fumble the ball purposefully because they are mad at their quarterback. Not voting for democrats/Obama would essentially be signing your own death warrant. We may not like these dems, but that just means we need to start financially supporting democrats that are more prone to union beliefs at both the local, state and national level. But if you think getting Obama out of office and opening the doors to Michelle "Homeschool" Bachmann is going to better the union cause on any level, then you need to stop drinking the hateerade. Obama may have let you down because he is not (gasp!) Dennis Kucinich, but that does not mean that we need to open the doors to those that not only want to but actively will abolish public sector unions. Don't believe me? Look northward, my friend, because Walkersconisn is only a state away.

November 10, 2020 at 6:35 AM

By: john whitfield

What will be in store for 'Centro America' under the newly elected government?

Who gave the 'nod and a wink' to the above aforementioned administration in Washington D.C. to go ahead with the plans to overthrow the government in Honduras? Plans left on the table by the preceding administration, that the secretary of state evidently blindly approved, and the former POTUS evidently blindly signed off on. From an elected government to a right wing government, not elected, but ousted in a coup. Honduras. We followed it closely in my H.S. Bilingual / Bi-cultural education class at George Washington H.S. with an 'Hondureno' present in that class helping us out to follow the developments. Your homework? What has TRUMP left on the table for for the new administration to be inaugurated in January? They shouldn't have to take out their Geography texts this time. In for example Nicaragua, when Trump took office, where the right wing immediately went to work to try to topple the elected government there, via NED(National Endowment for Democracy) and USAID (United States agency for International Development)among others (the U.S. Embassy in Managua) by funneling $$ to violent opposition groups who said up road blocks('tranques')killed dozens of policemen, and others associated with the elected political party. The coup in Nicaragua failed as the coup attempts have failed in Venezuela, but they haven't given up, while licking their blood thristy chops over Venezuelan oil. George published a piece I once penned 'Who Are the Terrorists?' And you would think that we would have learned more about our government's shananigan's in 'Centro America', having lived through the Iran-Contra /Affair. While we house many hundreds of young children in cages on the Mexican American border, that should be in our public school Bilingual / Bicultural education classes. (J.W, former Peace Corps volunteer, Costa Rica, and school teacher in Nicaragua, now retired, married to a Nicaraguan)

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

4 + 1 =