Duncan lies again... Harvard/Duke/Berkeley scholar takes a closer look at PISA results

While U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan seems to be escalating the lies and half-truths that have characterized his work since he was Chief Executive Officer of Chicago's public schools, for several months people across the USA have been taking a closer look at Duncan's claims and talking points (and even the version of his own history that he's been trying to peddle) and finding that much of what Duncan says is bunk.

Future U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan (above, second from left) shared the stage on December 11, 2008, promoting Chicago's merit pay with then U.S. Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings (third from left), Mayor Richard M. Daley (left), then Chicago Teachers Union President Marilyn Stewart, who supported all of Duncan's merit pay and other teacher firing programs ("Fresh Start"), and alderman Latasha Thomas (right). Substance photo by George N. Schmidt.The latest is a refutation published by a Harvard University scholar, noteworthy because Duncan's alma mater (Harvard) has produced more apologists for Duncan's policies that critics — at least so far.

U.S. schools aren't really falling behind says Berkeley professor and Harvard scholar Vivek Wadhwa, who took a closer look at Duncan's claims about the PISA.

In an official DOE press release, Duncan recently claimed:

“Today’s PISA results show that America needs to urgently accelerate student learning to remain competitive in the global economy of the 21st century. More parents, teachers, and leaders need to recognize the reality that other high-achieving nations are both out-educating us and out-competing us....The results are especially troubling because PISA assesses applied knowledge and the higher-order thinking skills critical to success in the information age.”

So says (not in those words, of course) Vivek Wadhwa, a visiting scholar at University of California-Berkeley, senior research associate at Harvard Law School, and director of research at the Center for Entrepreneurship and Research Commercialization at Duke University. And he says it in, of all places, Bloomberg Business Week, which seems of late to be taking notice of many of the scams that have cost the USA dearly of late.

Writing in Bloomberg BusinessWeek, Wadhwa argues:

"Much is made of the PISA test scores and rankings, but the international differences are actually quite small. Most of the U.S. ranking lags are not even statistically significant. The U.S. falls in the second rank on some measures and into the first on others. It produces more highest-performing students in science and reading than any other country does; in mathematics, it is second only to Japan. Moreover, one has to ask what the test results actually mean in the real world. Do high PISA rankings make students more likely to invent the next iPad? Google? I don't think so."

America's alarm about international rankings of students overlooks some critical components of our education system, Vivek Wadhwa says

By Vivek Wadhwa

America has an inferiority complex about its education system. You hear the sirens every year, when the OECD Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) releases its annual test results. Finland, South Korea, and Singapore usually come out on top; we start blaming our K-12 teachers for not teaching enough mathematics and science; we begin worrying about the millions of engineers and scientists China and India graduate.

This year the big surprise was that Shanghai garnered first place in the PISA rankings. Then The Wall Street Journal ran a story on the home page of its website titled "Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior." The Journal article claimed that Chinese (and Korean, Indian, etc.) parents raise "stereotypically successful kids"—math whizzes and music prodigies. They do this by not allowing their children to attend sleepovers; have a playdate; be in a school play; complain about not being in a school play; watch TV or play computer games; choose their own extracurricular activities; get any grade less than an A; not be the No. 1 student in every subject except gym and drama. The article went on to recount as typical a series of acts that would be considered child abuse in the U.S. (and aren't the norm in India and China).

The Journal article was simply bizarre, yet it is true that education in China and India is very challenging and fiercely competitive. Children are brought up to believe that education is everything, that it will make the difference between success and starvation. So from their early years they work long and hard. Most of their childhood is spent memorizing books on advanced subjects.

American Stereotypes

Meanwhile, the perception is that American children live a relatively easy life and coast their way through school. They don't do any more homework than they have to; they spend an extraordinary amount of time playing games, socializing on the Internet, text-messaging each other; they work part time to pay for their schooling and social habits. And they party. A lot. These stereotypes worry many Americans. They believe the American education system puts the country at a great disadvantage. But this is far from true.

The independence and social skills American children develop give them a huge advantage when they join the workforce. They learn to experiment, challenge norms, and take risks. They can think for themselves, and they can innovate. This is why America remains the world leader in innovation; why Chinese and Indians invest their life savings to send their children to expensive U.S. schools when they can. India and China are changing, and as the next generations of students become like American ones, they too are beginning to innovate. So far, their education systems have held them back.

My research team at Duke looked in depth at the engineering education of China and India. We documented that these countries now graduate four to seven times as many engineers as does the U.S.The quality of these engineers, however, is so poor that most are not fit to work as engineers; their system of rote learning handicaps those who do get jobs, so it takes two to three years for them to achieve the same productivity as fresh American graduates.As a result, significant proportions of China's engineering graduates end up working on factory floors and Indian industry has to spend large sums of money retraining its employees. After four or five years in the workforce, Indians do become innovative and produce, overall, at the same quality as Americans, but they lose a valuable two to three years in their retraining.

Rankings Reconsidered

And then there is the matter of the PISA rankings that supposedly show the U.S. trailing the rest of the world. Hal Salzman, a professor at Rutgers' John J. Heidrich Center for Workforce Development, debunked myths about these in a May 2008 article in Nature magazine. Salzman noted that international tests use different sampling criteria from country to country, so we're not always comparing apples to apples. As well, the tests compare select populations of small countries such as Singapore and Finland, which each have about 5 million people, with the U.S., which has 310 million. These countries achieve the top rankings on the PISA list. Compare these countries to similar-sized U.S. states, however, and you find that some of those states, including Massachusetts (population 6.5 million), produce the top students. Additionally, we're comparing America's diverse population—which includes disadvantaged minorities and unskilled immigrants with little education—with the homogeneous populations of countries like Finland, Japan, and New Zealand.

Much is made of the PISA test scores and rankings, but the international differences are actually quite small. Most of the U.S. ranking lags are not even statistically significant. The U.S. falls in the second rank on some measures and into the first on others. It produces more highest-performing students in science and reading than any other country does; in mathematics, it is second only to Japan. Moreover, one has to ask what the test results actually mean in the real world.

Do high PISA rankings make students more likely to invent the next iPad? Google (GOOG)? I don't think so.

Let's keep improving our education system and focus, in particular, on disadvantaged groups. Education is the future of our nation. But let's get over our inferiority complex. America is second to none. Rather than in mastery of facts learned by rote and great numbers of accomplished martinets, its strength lies in the diversity and innovation that arise in an open, creative society. 

Wadhwa is a visiting scholar at University of California-Berkeley, senior research associate at Harvard Law School, and director of research at the Center for Entrepreneurship and Research Commercialization at Duke University. Follow him on twitter—@vwadhwa .


December 21, 2023 at 5:15 AM

By: Bobiux


You don’t really should be the guy who's the life of the celebration; but even when life isn't good, having a great sense of humor works wonders. For day by day busy work, single folks don’t have enough time and can’t handle an opportunity to meet folks they like. The free relationship service has a user-friendly interface and permits you meet new individuals day-after-day! The international courting service permits you to look via and befriend single Ukrainian ladies, all via a easy systematic course of. Folks have the choice to filter potential companions primarily based on a selected nation; this allows them to connect with someone from an identical background or for people to observe a new language, amongst other things. If you want to get acquainted with girls from a specific nation, just pick the mandatory filter. Use these tricks to get started on making new buddies on Dream One Love!

Listed here are a number of instagram bio suggestions that you may want so as to add based on common traits. The first google results are principally from websites like zoosk and listed below are some tips on how to jot down a concise bio that may make it easier to appeal to the type of accomplice you need. Most of us have seen advertisements by a number of major online choices promising relationships with several testimonials from their customers on how profitable they have been to meet their life associate. One factor that basically works with online dating is listening to what the chat companion is saying. Let's chat on-line. To fulfill native people click the meetup near me button on the discuss rooms web page. One widespread remote job is live chat operator, a role that has seen significant progress in recent years. What Ought to I Write In My Dating Bio - 32 Best Opening Lines For Online Dating Websites And Courting Apps For Guys - It would not matter in case you write a courting profile that could be the following great american novel issues didn't work out however that was years in the past, and i'm prepared to satisfy somebody special right right here in my residence metropolis! Watch our documentary Addicted to Relationship Apps.

The corporate, which has presents up a web site and apps for daters world wide to search out one another, posted a web lack of $2.6 million in 2013 on revenues of $178 million. Report the matter to the courting website. How should a man write a courting profile? Writing it out on the video, she says: In this dating advice video from make him yours, i (mark rosenfeld, relationship and relationship coach) am what it's best to write in your online dating profile and the one thing men should see in your online dating. I've also included some writing exercises you. A quantity of individuals have received this before you and a woman is anticipated to obtain various such messages day by day. I just got out of college. It does not matter if you write a courting profile that may very well be the subsequent great american novel things didn't work out however that was years ago, and i'm ready to fulfill someone particular right right here in my home metropolis!

9 things it is best to definitely do in your relationship profile. One cause is as a result of their profile reads like a boring, relationship profile shaped turd. Do not flex your wealth, make crude, sexual jokes, or show off deadly weapons (e.g. It doesn't matter if you happen to write a dating profile that could possibly be the following nice american novel issues did not work out however that was years ago, and i am ready to fulfill somebody special proper right here in my residence city! Steal this trick from professional relationship profile writers! Don't write about what you do not like but keep things constructive as a substitute. Being mindful of your own personal safety and security will let you get pleasure from yourself and take advantage of your time chatting with new mates. Such a method will even be economical in phrases of cash and avoids qpid network unnecessary travel time. Many individuals beginning with online dating for the very first time believe in utilizing cheesy pickup strains.

December 24, 2023 at 4:10 AM

By: Kensnh

idateasia review

Essentially, the substantial bulk of days and matches acquired on IDateAsia are 100% successful as well as bloom to something magnificent and also attractive in no time. Guys, what are you waiting on? Are you disappointed of being fat as well as refused by women? A variety of ladies on these Asian seeking-love websites appreciate these kinds of western men. For instance, many western people like Thai food, which tastes a little spicy yet scrumptious! We won't evaluate individuals by his appearance, figure or wide range. A lot of western people are fascinated with Oriental culture as well as practices. Nonetheless, western females do not buy that and also they always pertain to fat individuals as the last option for a date. The blog also aims to supply helpful dating pointers, aiding participants fix dating and also connections issues as well as day wisely. Tips, understandings, dating as well as partnership fads and even more can be located below. So, jump on board today and delight in much more bliss. Currently, the net is an international hang around where you can get accounts of a a great deal of girls. Lots of lovely young ladies are seeking the benefits that can not be found in their ex-boyfriend, such as healthy body, honesty and also good temper.

Go find someone understanding your values as well as assets. That she left you may be partially because you're not an excellent male for her, yet it doesn't mean you're not a best suit for someone. While other adult pay websites continue to indulge in error, trying to match just with human experiences, IDateAsia counts a lot more on the computer to do the sorting and sifting; this in turn provides only the most suitable suit for gentlemen as well as women looking for love in Asia. This aspect is rather crucial if the affirmation that locating love is very easy, yet maintaining it is harder, is anything to go by. If you don't really feel that you are that far along in the relationship An additional choice you might wish to choose is a Love Phone call. Nevertheless, you needn't feel it in this way. They used to speak to single girls one-on-one as well as understand the specific timing as well as means to flirt her and make her laugh. They are not simply rather in the face alone, they are attractive, gifted, smart, and also enjoyable to be with. If you adhere to them, you are most likely to obtaining the success.

They are not certain while dating a single given that he has been married prior to. While the premium quality functions as well as solutions are identical to ChnLove, the main difference is that IDateAsia has members from numerous nations around Asia, not just in China. The companies are needed to adhere to certain regulations and also procedures and meet our high expectations for accuracy and honesty as demonstrated in the everyday interaction in between male and female participants. What is the very best means to meet Eastern ladies? You tell the website which lady you desire to meet and also a time that is hassle-free for you -IDateAsia will certainly manage the remainder for you. With TrustWave as well as GEoTrust firmly at the helms of events, you can feel confident that no spammer or defrauder can make it below. 2. Make on your own attractive.Many divorced guys just remain their way of living as well as look as that prior to separation. No one desires divorce! Sign up to IDateAsia for a double combo; first, you obtain to find the finest and also most enchanting Oriental, and afterwards you break out analysis services from the website; both for the price of one. In our following IDateAsia review we explain why this is among the most prominent Eastern dating websites on-line today. Why not shed extra pounds and also keep a terrific shape before dating a person? The hectic job and also abundant socialized life leave us little time to do the workout and keep fit. You must try your finest to leave excellent impacts to them

. 1. Support up and leave your divorce behind. So today I'm gon na idateasia review speak about just how to start a new connection after separation. The website's experts likewise follow each as well as every connection to make sure there are no issues with language or cultural adaptation. Yet when it appears as well as there is no other way for you to transform the marital relationship, you would certainly much better discover to accept it and also move on. Yet it's gon na be alright, man You require to progress and live your life. Nonetheless, you must not lie concerning those advantages, all you require to do is reveal the actual you in front of her. 1. Show your advantages. Getting credit scores can end up being expensive if you negligent..

February 21, 2024 at 2:22 AM

By: Danielszg

charmdate scam

It also features sources for singles to assist them discover the right accomplice and know extra about what they want in another individual. We've acquired singles from throughout Europe, from Albania, Armenia, Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Macedonia, Netherlands, Norway, Malta, Montenegro, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Ukraine, and United Kingdom. There are many sites that specialize in becoming a member of singles with Ukrainian girls, however not every one among them are made equal. However, it is very important remember that not all of those sites are created equal. However, it is important to recollect that every European guy is completely different, so you will need to get to know him before making any choices. However, there may be some slight differences. Yes, there are websites for European hookups in the UK. So where do single jap European women esp. I feel extra comfy courting jap European women as a result of ukrainian my background. If you’re on the lookout for a associate who shares your cultural background or just has an appreciation for it, these are the best European dating websites for you.

Love is not at all times simple to search out, however you've arrived at our genuine site for Christian Europeans who know their religion is important when searching for a relationship. You could find stereotypes about courting Europeans on heaps of various websites and boards. By relationship somebody from a unique place, you may learn new methods of thinking and improve your own understanding of the world. You too can achieve a wider perspective by yourself tradition by relationship somebody from one other part of the world. These stereotypes may be harmful, since they paint a really broad picture of Europeans as a group. Most Europeans don’t day simply anyone, and they’ll search out flaws in a accomplice. It’s harder for a US individual to decide on just one particular person and settle around, however Europeans don’t listen to any other temptations being in relationships. It’s also important to be upfront about any dealbreakers.

It’s better to be up entrance about who you might be and what you’re in search of. Additionally, they are often in search of a severe relationship. Additionally, you will need to learn critiques of relationship websites before making a ultimate decision. Additionally, there are a number of filters to go looking by “sect, ethnicity, religiousity, dress, how a lot they pray how a lot they pray and lots of more”. UAbrides is without doubt one of the fewest charmingdate Ukrainian relationship web sites which can be so wealthy in quite a few essentially the most lovely ladies. So try our record of high European dating websites and sign up for one today! European dating websites are more open to different types of relationships than some other web sites. They also are inclined to have more members, since European dating websites cater to a wider viewers. How to choose a European dating site that is ideal for you? How to decide on the best European dating site within the UK? Consequently, European ladies can make very good conversation associates. There are so many various cultures, norms and traditions that it may be arduous to navigate them unexpectedly. In reality, there isn’t a lot distinction between courting a European individual and relationship somebody from one other a part of the world.

UAbrides unites individuals from all corners of one of the vital beautiful nation on the earth. If yes, be happy to join the UAbrides group. Thankfully, there are some trustworthy dating websites that provide free Ukraine dating services. Yes, there are some free European dating websites within the UK. If a girl is lively on the positioning, be happy to contact her by mail, chat, or send an EOI (expression of interest) to find out if she would like to fulfill you. Join to 50 000 profitable men like you and follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram or Telegram. Once they might not be mainly as a result of romantic as their European equivalent, asian European men are still extremely chivalrous. By relationship a European person, you'll be able to break down these harmful stereotypes and get to know a real particular person. You'll be able to let individuals know what you’re serious about and what sort of relationship you’re on the lookout for. If you end up in search of love, a woman for a relationship, you must all the time watch out. With it, you would possibly see your girl and consider how she reacts and behaves in non-commonplace situations. As an example, you would possibly mention her age, and so on. Then, Ukrainian ladies courting sites will discover you a couple of ladies to pick out from.

March 1, 2024 at 3:53 AM

By: Skyesbxp

asiame scam

He arrives at your door, perhaps flowers in hand-and you'll only hope you’ll return home feeling like Cinderella, sealing the night time with a passionate farewell kiss. It’s economical, irritated can easily be carried out at your private home. It’s a good suggestion to concentrate on something you like to do-one thing enjoyable typically relieves inevitable anxiety. Are you looking at having a great time or are you seeking at a serious relationship outcome? Good for me! The extra worth for me personally then turned learning the concepts excellent ad imitate. They place their newly learned expertise to use, taking concrete steps to strengthen their efficiency, therefore can take their enterprise to another level. I felt like I simply didn't have Paris enterprise address the expertise and the feeling I wanted, as a result of Employed nonetheless coaching. I work rather a lot but I’m lucky to have such a fantastic job and profession. • Your likes and dislikes means quite a bit for Mingle2, so taking good care of this now Mingle2 brings the benefit to whom you need chat and date and to whom you need to block in your profile. 5. Block People Within Dating: You'll be able to block individuals in Facebook Dating without affecting your relationship on other components of Facebook.

The advantages of online dating are that you may create a profile for your self that connects you with people which are suitable with what you might be on the lookout for in a partner. Together with others in Europe and the US, Younis began in search of samosa-free methods to help younger Muslims tie the knot, and Muslim on-line matchmaking was born. She was born in Jamaica and now resides in Tampa, Florida, together with her husband, Tovares, and their two youngsters. In one other study, the researchers introduced contributors with one in every of two situations wherein they ran into an acquaintance at a celebration who either forgot their name or whose title they forgot. While it may be true that some folks place very much emphasis on bodily appearances, the underside line is it does make an enchancment when two totally different individuals are assembly and making initial evaluations of their curiosity in each other. Article advertising is a very effectual means of helping people perceive a problem or amusing them, while your advert sits finish of it the page ready for that curious to click on so it. You possibly can post copies of your article to the of range blogs and article databases on the online world.

Sometimes finding a special particular person can change your world utterly. When you have been promoting on the net on the web world you’ve most likely heard how vital it to have the ability to have an electronic mail checklist. So far every part that you’ve stated about the confidence part is absolutely important. This process of preliminary anonymity allows folks to achieve the arrogance needed for meeting new folks. While some folks tend to enroll the title in the league just for enjoyable, others are led in direction of the approach to shun the continuous disappointments in real life. In some methods online dating is a unique ballgame from scam assembly somebody in actual life - and in some ways it’s not. It's necessary to build belief earlier than you share intimate photos with somebody. Is this a blind date, Internet date, or with someone you already know? You by no means know who turns out to be an impostor. I would keep away from disclosing your visual incapacity immediately since you really don’t know this particular person and undecided of their intent. That's right - relationships simply got added to the checklist of things that may be outsourced, similar to shopping for groceries, paying bills or painting your automobile.

Painting a false image of yourself in any person's mind will not allow you to form a long run relationship. The picture phase is intended to be a design of the dater's life and in addition life-style and usually entails a portrait shot and a few full physique pictures and so on. Then once more, life is stuffed with rejection is it not? Again, it allows you to ship your love an ecard or a love notice through e-mail or chat. Several web sites are available at this time which attracts people and make promises to seek out true love for them. There can be days in a relationship where it's possible you'll feel like, I don’t like this individual in the present day, however you choose to love them anyway as a result of you might be dedicated to making the relationship work and you love them. Depending on how old you might be you may have already got a steady girlfriend or boyfriend otherwise you possibly limiting yourself to informal online dating for the second. What technique have you been using when you are with a girl you are drawn to? Some online dating profiles are so cringe-worthy, they’re comical.

March 1, 2024 at 6:30 AM

By: Johnyei

latamdate review

Through the problems we dealt with, we sought aid in therapy, and now we both work as relationship therapists. "The thing with the classics, we've heard them, and we comprehend the language, because it has influenced what we are listening to now. Are you... are you in a relationship? If they are not already in yours), volunteer to do some work for their company (. Relationship management intends to create a collaboration in between a company and its clients, instead of viewing the relationship as merely transactional. Nguyen, B, Lee-Wingate, SN & Simkin, L (2014 ), The customer relationship management paradox: Five steps to develop a fairer organisation Social Business, vol. Modern marketers try to reinforce consumer-brand relationships, which produces advantages for the business such as lowered marketing costs, ease of access to customers, acquiring new clients, client retention, brand name equity, and more profit. Public relationship marketing is most effective when it is customized to each market and customer sector. Each market might require its own specific techniques and marketing mix. Remember, the range might be challenging, however with efficient interaction, you can get rid of any barrier and make your long-distance relationship work. This can assist you make the finest choices on your own or for an enjoyed one.

This may take just a couple of minutes a week, but those few minutes can make the difference in assisting your friend or co-worker keep in mind latamdate the significance of the work you are doing together. To achieve this, you may use the withCount technique. Use the Manage relationships dialog box to set a relationship as active or inactive, or set the active relationship in the Edit relationship dialog box. Ending the damage and preconception of domestic violence needs a nuanced understanding of what abuse is, in addition to examples of healthy relationships. Domestic violence (likewise described as intimate partner violence (IPV), dating abuse, or relationship abuse) is a pattern of behaviors utilized by one partner to keep power and control over another partner in an intimate relationship. Domestic violence does not discriminate. People of any race, age, gender, sexuality, faith, education level, or economic status can be a victim - or wrongdoer - of domestic violence. When things get tough, which they will, individuals with this belief are more likely to think they slipped up in selecting this individual and give up on the relationship completely, to move on to find their "real soul mate". In other words, organization partners are most likely to be faithful when there's a much better connection between the 2.

After almost 2 years together, Wilde and Styles are pressing time out on their romance. After 2 years of sorting through the information, here's what he and his team noticed. We have been together for 25 years and the ups and downs of our journey have actually taught us not just that these low points are normal, but that the repair work process can develop trust and deepen intimacy. Consider what makes you not trust somebody. If you trust your relationship enough, you might even admit it to them. An assumption that your level of curiosity, generosity, versatility and interest will withstand, and even increase, throughout your relationship. Its advocates have previously demonstrated they are open to the idea of being challenged, even with an opera told by means of flashbacks. A police officer has admitted having an unsuitable relationship with a lady being investigated for a criminal offense. I remember sort of needing to peel myself far from jumping off the veranda.

Doubts might crowd your head-about how much they like you, what they want, whether it's prematurely to ask. That level of understanding assists when it comes to a production like Ainadamar as much of the story takes place in the mind and memory of Xirgu. Wilde was likewise quoted in the cover story and spoke with the outlet about her experience with Styles' zealous fans. He argued that the essence of relationship marketing is to bring in, establish and preserve a close relationship with business customers. Thank consumers through a social networks post or with a surprise present card. The trigger fizzles out as there's no area between you, no magnetism. 9. Develop selective amnesia There's an 80/20 guideline that if your relationship is OK 80% of the time, then that's great enough. This totals up to concentrating on the capacity for gain (closeness) rather than the potential for loss (rejection), which parallels the examinations of effects that ought to lead to relative obstacle vs threat, respectively. They are so scared of rejection and isolation, that they are indicate to others who they deem a hazard. Lots of people are trying to find a chance to meet other people who share typical objectives.

Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

3 + 5 =