Duncan continues silly defenses of 'higher standards', Common Core, and corporate reform ripoffs...

Thanks to blogger Mercedes Schneider, we have the following analysis of the latest nonsense from Arne Duncan, as the PARCC and other Common Core scores come out. AS noted again, Duncan is claiming, along with a dwindling number of ruling class apologists (including still the editors of The New York Times and Chicago Tribune) that the former state "standards" were a cop out, and that the federal government had to jump in with Common Core in order to stop 50 states and millions of teachers and students and families from supposedly gaming the system. The URL for this analysis is:


Arne Duncan in Pittsburgh, Selling Low Common Core Test Scores, September 19, 2015

On September 18, 2015, US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan stopped in Pittsburgh at private university, Carnegie Mellon, to promote Common Core and its tests.

During that visit, Duncan said that the signature low scores on Common Core tests did not mean that students were less smart than they were six months ago or a year ago.

However, two years ago, in November 2013, Duncan said some mothers were indeed realizing that their kids werent so smart:

Its fascinating to me that some of the pushback [toward Common Core] is coming from, sort of, white suburban moms who all of a sudden their child isnt as brilliant as they thought they were and their school isnt quite as good as they thought they were.

Nevertheless, both in November 2013 and in September 2015, Duncan assures the public that the problem is with states former, lower standards.

Yet Duncan offers no empirical evidence to support this statement to his Carnegie Mellon audience, as reported in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:

The secretary said children and parents were lied to and told they were on the track to be successful when they werent. He called that one of the most insidious things that happened in education.

And yet, Duncans own legacy as Chicago Public Schools CEO left test score results that show that Chicago students under him might have already been lied to by a Duncan who by 2009 had moved on to the White Houseand to actively promoting Common Core and its tests. As the December 2009 Washington Post reports:

Soon after Arne Duncan left his job as schools chief here to become one of the most powerful U.S. education secretaries ever, his former students sat for federal achievement tests. This month, the mathematics report card was delivered: Chicago trailed several cities in performance and progress made over six years.

Miami, Houston and New York had higher scores than Chicago on the National Assessment of Educational Progress. Boston, San Diego and Atlanta had bigger gains. Even fourth-graders in the much-maligned D.C. schools improved nearly twice as much since 2003.

The federal readout is just one measure of Duncans record as chief executive of the nations third-largest system. Others show advances on various fronts. But the new math scores signal that Chicago is nowhere near the head of the pack in urban school improvement, even though Duncan often cites the successes of his tenure as he crusades to fix public education. [Emphasis added.]

Duncan will sell what is convenient to sell in the moment. And right now, his product of choice is the low Common Core test score.

Another notable issue is that Duncan enrolled his own children in school in Virginia, which is not a Common Core state.

Does that mean he is lying to himself and telling himself that his sans-Common-Core children are on track to be successful defying via his personal life the Duncan-declared Common Core Guarantee?

Perhaps he is simply revealing what Bill Gates admitted in March 2014 when asked if he wanted Common Core for his own children.

Gates responded that he wanted more.

But both Gates and Duncan would sell Common Core to the masses.

According to the Post-Gazette, Duncan also asserts that students needing to take remedial courses in college as proof that the old standards didnt work (Post-Gazette paraphrase of Duncan).

Duncan offers no empirical evidence establishing a direct connection between state standards and college remediation rates, and he offers no empirical evidence that Common Core and its necessary tests will reduce college remediation rates.

He simply declares it to be so. Duncan declares Common Core as higher; he declares the cause-effect relationship between state standards and college remediation rates; he declares Common Core as superior, and he declares that lower scores on Common Core tests will directly and assuredly translate into reduced college remediation rates.

Of course, his US secretary of education days are numbered, and he will not have to answer for any of his pompous declarations.

And his kids, now attending the University of Chicago Lab School, will face no low scores on Common Core tests, for once again, there is no Common Core at the school they attend.

Ahh, the duplicity of the privileged Common Core promoter.


Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

4 + 5 =