British tabloid scandal puts Murdoch school reform agenda in spotlight

[Editor's introduction. The following article came over the wires today from Agence Global. Viewers saw former New York City schools chancellor Joel Klein sitting directly behind Rupert Murdoch during his Parliament ‘grilling’ this week — reminding school reformers of a series of sweetheart deals between New York and News Corp. Klein was hired by Murdoch after he left the job at New York city's public schools, and Mayor Michael Bloomberg put Cathi Black in charge].

Muroch executive Joel Klein (above left) and Princess Friyal of Jordan at a May 2010 charity event on Long Island. Klein, who served as New York City Schools Chancellor is now a major apologist for corporate school reform in the media, despite the failures of his own programs while he ran the New York City schools under Mayor Michael Bloomberg. Klein, a former U.S. Justice Department lawyer, now works for News Corp on getting contracts to privatize public school services for Rupert Murdoch's media empire and was present in London during the recent hearings on the tabloids' phone hacking and other illegal activities. Scrutiny Turns to Murdoch’s School Reform Agenda by Dana Goldstein

If you watched Rupert Murdoch’s weak-sauce testimony in front of the British Parliament Tuesday, you might have felt just a teensy bit sorry for former New York City schools chancellor Joel Klein, who sat directly behind Murdoch the entire afternoon, pouting.

Sure, Klein is probably earning more money than God in his new role as executive vice president at News Corp. But the Justice Department attorney-turned data-and-accountability school reformer signed up with Murdoch to get out of the harsh political limelight and help News Corp make a mint selling educational technology products to school districts. Instead, Klein now finds himself heading up the company’s internal response to the explosive phone hacking scandal, which has tainted nearly every august institution in British society, from Fleet Street to the Cameron government to Scotland Yard.

The FBI is currently investigating News Corp. to learn if its illegal and unethical activities victimized any American citizens, or penetrated the company’s US holdings, which include Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, and the New York Post.

But what’s been less well-understood is the impact the scandal might have on Murdoch’s attempt to make a profit off of the American public sector, most notably through seeking to provide technology services, such as data-tracking systems and video lessons, to public school districts. Last November, shortly after hiring Klein, News Corp. acquired Wireless Generation, an education technology firm that had worked closely with Klein during his tenure as chancellor on two projects: ARIS, a controversial (and buggy) data system that warehouses students’ standardized test scores and demographic profiles; and School of One, a more radical attempt to use technology to personalize instruction, reorganize classrooms, and reduce the size of the teaching force.

The acquisition put Klein, who was set to supervise Wireless Generation, in an awkward position vis a vis city ethics regulations. The Times reported:

Conflict-of-interest rules set strict limits for city employees, both during and after their tenure, which could make Mr. Klein’s transition a tricky one. City employees are never allowed to disclose confidential information about the city’s business dealings or future strategy, and they cannot communicate with the agency for which they worked for one year after they leave. The rules also bar them from ever working on matters they had substantial involvement in as city employees.

It seemed unlikely Klein would be able to fully follow those mandates when, in May, the city Department of Education renewed its contract with Wireless Generation, asking the company to provide testing materials and software. Last month, New York State moved to award Wireless Generation a $27 million no-bid contact to create a state student data-tracking system similar to ARIS -- despite the fact that many New York City principals have decided not to use the $80 million software, which doesn’t track helpful day-to-day information on attendance, behavior, or homework completion.

So far, only the teachers’ union and a few New York progressive organizations -- including the Working Families Party, Common Cause/New York, and New York City Public School Parents -- are using the hacking scandal to call attention to what they see as a series of sweetheart deals between New York and News Corp. Wireless Generation Senior Vice President Zachary Silverstein told Education Week that drawing any connection between Murdoch’s UK troubles and his American education business is “is really a stretch and frankly unfair.”

But scrutiny on Murdoch’s school agenda is growing. Aware of the media titan’s relationship with former D.C. schools chancellor Michelle Rhee, education reporter Alexander Russo tried to find out if Murdoch had donated to StudentsFirst, Rhee’s PAC. The group’s goal is to act as a political counterweight to teachers’ unions.

“After two days of emails and phone calls -- they must have been freaking out behind the scenes trying to figure out what to do -- a Rhee spokesperson would neither confirm nor deny the Murdoch money,” Russo wrote.

“Our policy doesn't allow me to reveal who our donors are or aren't,” the spokesman said.

Dana Goldstein is a Puffin Foundation writing fellow at The Nation Institute and a Schwartz Fellow at the New America Foundation. Her writing on education, women's issues, public health, and American politics has appeared in The Daily Beast, The American Prospect, The Nation, the Washington Post, The New Republic, Slate and BusinessWeek.


Add your own comment (all fields are necessary)

Substance readers:

You must give your first name and last name under "Name" when you post a comment at We are not operating a blog and do not allow anonymous or pseudonymous comments. Our readers deserve to know who is commenting, just as they deserve to know the source of our news reports and analysis.

Please respect this, and also provide us with an accurate e-mail address.

Thank you,

The Editors of Substance

Your Name

Your Email

What's your comment about?

Your Comment

Please answer this to prove you're not a robot:

5 + 1 =